I have officially had The New Xbox Experience.
I'd like the old one back, please.
First, what I *did* like. The new blade system is quite nice - a little easier to sort out than the old, mostly because it takes out some of the fluff and just keeps it simple with text and small icons. The fact that you can access any blade (Marketplace, Game Library, Media, and Settings) from anywhere is handy, too. Unfortunately, I like it mostly because of its similarity to the old Dashboard. It's as if the entire Dashboard was compressed into the Blade system, while Microsoft designed the NXE to take its place.
So, let's talk about the NXE Dashboard. When you boot up the console, it takes you to the Welcome Channel. Yeah, they even had the gall to call them "Channels" like the Wii. Take a look for yourself... how would you start playing the game you've got in the disc drive?
It took me a few seconds to notice "My Xbox" dimly visible above. In fact, that's where you'll find the currently inserted disc. So I loaded it up, then quit out of the game... and was back at the Welcome Channel, forced to navigate back up to "My Xbox" to re-enter the game. While I realize there are still less actions involved than on the old Dashboard, it's not about the number of steps. It's about their clarity. Strike 1.
Since I don't need a tutorial on using my Xbox every time I log in, I set about looking for a way to turn off the Welcome Channel. I found it in My Xbox>Settings, switched it off lickity-split, and pressed (B) to return to the Dashboard proper.
Pop Quiz: How do you get back to play your game?
Answer: It's "simple." Just hold [LEFT] to scroll back to the top of the My Xbox Channel.
Real answer: There's nothing simple about it, because there is absolutely no indication that there exists content to the left of your current "position." Again not an issue of functionality, but one of clarity. Strike 2.
I went back into the game, and then backed out to the Dashboard. The Welcome Channel was safely disabled, so I was helpfully returned to the
Update: Apparently, my original Strike 3 is not an issue on the public version of Xbox Live, only on the developer side ("PartnerNet"). Luckily, I found a brand new Strike 3!
I decided to redeem a code for some free goodies -- the same codes you'd use for an XBLive time card, a Points card, or any game's exclusive DLC. In this case, it's the Rock Band Track Pack Volume 2 (a collection of DLC). On the old Dashboard, you simply went to the Marketplace and selected "Redeem Code"... on the New Xbox Experience, no such luck.
I looked for a good 10 minutes or more for SOMEWHERE to input a redemption code. I looked in Marketplace, My Xbox, System Settings, everywhere. It was nowhere to be found. Eventually I decided to take advantage of one of Microsoft's much-touted new features, the ability to purchase DLC on the web and have your console automatically begin downloading it (provided it's turned on, which wastes quite a bit of power). Even then it took some digging to find the code entry page.
Thankfully, a coworker showed me where to find the Code Entry dialogue in the NXE, and the answer is one that I'm increasingly finding solves *all* the issues I have with the new interface: hit the Guide Button and pull up the Blades. They're like a text-only version of the old Dashboard, and offer massive amounts of improved functionality over the NXE's flashy-but-useless approach. In this case, just pop up the Blades and scroll Left to the Marketplace tab... voila. "Redeem Code" right there, as if it had been waiting for you this whole time.
It's summary time! I know NXE offers a host of new features. I'm very curious to check out streaming HD Netflix. The potential of "gaming parties" (a group of friends migrating from game to game without losing each other) sounds pretty cool. Technically, none of the functionality of the original Dashboard has been lost.
BUT the whole experience is wrapped up in the most cumbersome, unintuitive, and (seemingly deliberately) information-obscuring interface I've seen in a LONG time. Even simple decisions like the default channel have been buggered up. There's nothing crippling by itself, but the number of poor design decisions (magnified by the extremely consistent design) add up to a drastically diminished user experience.
I am not a wrathful blogger... merely an opinionated one (Hm, why is the Department of Redundancy Department calling my cell now?). And so, here's my opinion:
1) "My Xbox" should be the default channel, and there should be an option in Settings to change that. If you HAVE to have an ad on the default channel, put one in. I won't mind.
2) Ditch the "receding into the distance" thing. It's uninformative, and every piece of information that scrolls off the left side of the screen might as well no longer exist. Instead, why not use a spinner or loop? Let the user scroll in either direction, all the way around the circle, seeing other options in the distance behind. I'm thinking of the song select screen from the original DDR or Donkey Konga.
3) MORE INFORMATION. Tell me I can navigate right AND left. Give me some game art and a summary of XBLA titles without having to enter the game itself -- pop up a little window with information when you highlight a title. Let me see the title without having to physically select it -- at least the first four or five titles in a list.
Update: 4) Make it at least as functional as the old interface. If there was something easily done on the old Dashboard that cannot be as easily done on the new, You're Doing It Wrong.
I hope Microsoft isn't done with this new execution. I wish they'd let it bake a little longer before pulling it out of the oven and dropping it in our laps. Sadly, we don't have a choice in whether or not to use it... but hopefully they'll hear the voices of frustrated gamers and take action to repair their oversights.